This morning Chris Brogan, social media prince, wrote a blog talking about the possible creation of a city information center (what he calls a city news feed) on the web. Brogan suggested that the police blotter, feeds from the fire department, gps data about the location of public transit, everything that you might want to know, be put on a single site.
This kind of thinking is right up our alley at Renaissance – although I haven’t finished my set of utopian posts about what Fort Worth should be like, I haven’t given up on the concept either — but the main questions about the concept of a city data information center of the type Brogan describes would be
1. Who’d pay for it;
2. Who’d write it and
2. Who’d be allowed or forced to participate once it’s constructed.
As we’ve said before, a local hub where blogs can post their news and views is something we’ve discussed with other bloggers in the area. But a blog hub isn’t what Brogan is talking about — he seems to be thinking more of updates from the police and ambulance crew. I have a vision of some clerk in some office saying, “hold on, hold on, I’ve got to update our feed … ”
Or, alternatively, I suppose, cops could digitally enter their crime reports on a hand-held device and then the second they’re turned in to the office a data abstract could appear on a the city’s website feed, something like:
“6-23-09 7:00 a.m. … car burglary … 27th and Vine…. district 36 …. laptop computer, wallet stolen … officer # 2345″ with a hyperlink on the type of crime (so you could see all the others) and the district and the day ….
Some people might feel compelled to read this stuff (wow, officer 2345 really gets around, he’s listed more than any other police operative) but for many, would it just be a bunch of datapoints which are ultimately minimally comprehensible?
Because, and here’s the kicker, data needs analysis and in general, there has been no way discovered to digest, interpret, and present data in easily digestible chunks except a person whose qualifications are basically in the journalistic line.
Therefore, if the city had an RSS feed — it would be up to the city to hire someone to put the data into usable form. I suppose this could provide work for some laid off writers from the Star Telegram. But with the cutting of the library hours and the paucity of public pools and other recreation opportunities — a post is upcoming on that — I doubt Fort Worth will be doing something bold and innovative in this line any time this decade. I mean, maybe after New York or Washington proves is works, but not yet.
For today, the best way to find out about crime in your local area is to ask a local police officer.
7 Comments
Leave a Reply
RECENT POSTS
| S | M | T | W | T | F | S |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| « Jan | ||||||
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | |||
| 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 |
| 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 |
| 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 | 24 | 25 |
| 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 | |||
What an interesting post. I like the idea in concept and yes, it seems way to progressive for our city. I think that organizations, businesses, municipalities, etc. could start figuring out that they can provide valuable services to their communities by being their own media outlet.
Technologies are getting easier to use and implement, then, as you rightfully point out, add in some analysis and you have remarkable opportunities for additional open government through dynamic information sharing. However, it takes strong (and confident) leadership who is interested in a culture of transparency. Unfortunately, that is not as easy to come by as an RSS feed these days.
I’m a little chagrinned to think that you agree that Fort Worth is not a highly technologically innovative city … although we both know it’s true. If they HAD an RSS feed .. how many would actually be able to figure out how to read it?
We must set up the foundations for digital communication now to be ready for when awareness begins to rise. But right now, digital awareness is FW is sleeping in, like my teenaged sons. It may take a tornado or other disaster to wake it up.
Hello Sonja! I read Brogan’s post regarding this one. I have to agree that it will be a bold move for a city to do such. I love FW but I don’t think that a project like this should be spearheaded by the city government. Not that I’m questioning their abilities but I would rather listen to a group, like what Richie mentioned, who is interested in a culture of transparency.
This will be one heck of a project. I’m looking into it as a localized Twitter just for a particular city.
Hi Sonja!
I love the idea of an RSS feed for the City of Fort Worth. Although, it’s a challenging concept at the moment, it could work in the future. Hmmm…I can visualize everyone communicating in real-time. Even with 911 emergencies…or news that happens instantly in your specific area. This is a very interesting idea…
Hi Cindy — the truth is, I think it could work, but I’m not sure who would pay for it and edit it. I agree with Rob that giving the project to the city would present some problems, but without them controlling it, would they allow their data to be used?
Maybe I should ask someone from the city to answer that.
It is a decent concept, but we can’t expect our policemen to become bloggers, or twitters, or RSS data suppliers either.
Currently, there is a something similar to what you are talking about though (limited to crime) on dallasfortworthcrime.com. I have also seen similar map mashups for foreclosures in the area.
Your assumption that only journalists can churn the data is hugely inaccurate. And no city employee has to churn the data. The data is already there – it’s just not available to the public or in any standard format. All the city has to do is standardize the data and make it available from a single place (crime, trash, transportation, road conditions, construction, etc…). The public has hundreds of mobile app developers that can create programs to digest the raw data. Some will be published free and some will be sold, but in the end – you will have a better informed public.
San Francisco has a site where you can take pictures of potholes or streetlights and upload them (including GPS coordinates) and the city can be instantly notified of a problem and work to correct it.
There needs to be no RSS feed or anything done differently by policemen and firemen and etc… I guarantee the data is probably digitized already in some way after the reports are submitted.